Settlement Alerts:

$9,250,000 Defamation Case Win Against The New York Times 8/26
$6,800,000 Wrongful Death 8/26
$81,000,000 Children Born Addicted (as part of the trial team)
$18,000,000 Product Liability 12/19
$13,000,000 Medical Malpractice – Sexual Assault 8/23
$225,000 Civil Litigation 7/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$30,000 Medical Malpractice 7/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$42,690 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$2,759,223 Opioid Litigation 6/26
$70,000 Medical Malpractice 6/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 6/26
$100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$420,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$650,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
$46,937 Opioid Litigation 5/26
$150,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 5/26
$285,000 Medical Malpractice 4/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Personal Injury 3/26
$40,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$32,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$42,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 1/26
$30,000 Personal Injury 1/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$77,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$26,668 Personal Injury 9/25
$25,000 Personal Injury 9/25
$97,500 Personal Injury 9/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$100,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 8/25
$100,000 Wrongful Death 7/25
$45,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/25
$200,000 Wrongful Death 6/25
$1,200,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 6/25
$200,000 Slip & Fall 6/25
$26,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
$800,000 Jail Litigation 5/25
$925,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$125,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$700,000 Jail Litigation 4/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$125,000 Personal Injury 4/25
$20,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
$1,300,000 Jail Litigation 2/25
$210,000 Slip & Fall 2/25
$100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
$975,000 Medical Malpractice 1/25
$4,000,000 Jail Litigation 1/25

$9,250,000 Defamation & False Light 8/26
$6,800,000 Wrongful Death 8/26
$81,000,000 Children Born Addicted (as part of the trial team)
$18,000,000 Product Liability 12/19
$13,000,000 Medical Malpractice – Sexual Assault 8/23
$225,000 Civil Litigation 7/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$30,000 Medical Malpractice 7/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$42,690 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
$2,759,223 Opioid Litigation 6/26
$70,000 Medical Malpractice 6/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 6/26
$100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$420,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
$650,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
$46,937 Opioid Litigation 5/26
$150,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 5/26
$285,000 Medical Malpractice 4/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
$50,000 Personal Injury 3/26
$40,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$32,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
$42,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 1/26
$30,000 Personal Injury 1/26
$50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$77,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$26,668 Personal Injury 9/25
$25,000 Personal Injury 9/25
$97,500 Personal Injury 9/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
$100,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 8/25
$100,000 Wrongful Death 7/25
$45,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/25
$200,000 Wrongful Death 6/25
$1,200,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 6/25
$200,000 Slip & Fall 6/25
$26,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
$800,000 Jail Litigation 5/25
$925,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$125,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$700,000 Jail Litigation 4/25
$25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
$125,000 Personal Injury 4/25
$20,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
$1,300,000 Jail Litigation 2/25
$210,000 Slip & Fall 2/25
$100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
$975,000 Medical Malpractice 1/25
$4,000,000 Jail Litigation 1/25

CALL US NOW

5-Star Google Rating•BBB Rating: A+•West Virginia State Bar•The United States District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia•The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals•The United States Supreme Court•American Association for Justice•Opioid Justice Team•Trial Lawyers Care•West Virginia Association for Justice•5-Star Google Rating•BBB Rating: A+•West Virginia State Bar•The United States District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia•The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals•The United States Supreme Court•American Association for Justice•Opioid Justice Team•Trial Lawyers Care•West Virginia Association for Justice

TENORM Lawyer in Mineral Wells

Radiation Contamination Claims

Complete Guide to TENORM Claims

TENORM refers to Technologically Enhanced Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials that can be concentrated or redistributed by industrial processes. In Mineral Wells and surrounding Wood County communities, TENORM can arise from oil and gas operations, coal combustion residues, scrap recycling, and waste handling. Exposure to contaminated soil, dust, water, or building materials may cause long-term environmental and health concerns for residents, workers, and property owners. This guide explains common exposure pathways, legal remedies that may be available, and practical steps people in Mineral Wells can take to document incidents and protect their rights while pursuing recovery for harm and contamination.

Stephen New & Associates serves clients across West Virginia, including those in Mineral Wells, with matters involving hazardous contamination and personal injury related to TENORM incidents. Our Beckley-based firm handles claims arising from workplace exposure, property contamination, and community releases, helping clients navigate reporting to state agencies, arranging environmental testing, and pursuing claims for property loss and personal injury. If you or a loved one suspects exposure to TENORM, it is important to understand your options early, preserve evidence, and get clear guidance on deadlines, medical monitoring, and coordination with public health authorities and regulatory agencies.

Why Addressing TENORM Matters

Taking legal action after a TENORM exposure can result in meaningful outcomes beyond financial compensation. Effective claims can secure testing and remediation of contaminated property, require responsible parties to fund environmental cleanup, and ensure ongoing monitoring where long‑term risks exist. Legal processes also create formal records and inspections that help communities understand the scope of contamination and push for stronger safety measures. For individuals and families, pursuing a claim can obtain compensation for medical evaluation, treatment, lost earnings, and diminished property value, while holding companies and managers accountable for unsafe practices that led to contamination.

About Stephen New & Associates

Stephen New & Associates is a Personal Injury Law Firm located in Beckley, West Virginia, representing clients across the state, including Mineral Wells. The firm focuses on cases involving environmental contamination, workplace injury, medical harm, and serious accidents, bringing together investigative resources, medical contacts, and litigation capability to pursue claims on behalf of affected individuals and families. The team communicates directly with clients about investigation steps, coordinates environmental testing and medical evaluations, and works to secure compensation or remediation that addresses both current impacts and potential future harms arising from TENORM exposure.

Understanding TENORM and Your Legal Options

TENORM describes naturally occurring radioactive elements that become concentrated or redistributed through industrial activity. Common sources include scales and sludges from oil and gas extraction, residues from coal combustion, certain mining wastes, and materials recycled from industrial equipment. Exposure pathways include inhalation of contaminated dust, ingestion of impacted water or food, and direct contact with contaminated soil or surfaces. Health and property risks vary with the type and level of contamination, so prompt assessment and sampling by qualified environmental professionals are important to determine whether hazardous levels are present and to identify the parties responsible for the release.

Legal claims involving TENORM may include personal injury suits for health effects, property damage claims for reduced value or contamination, and actions seeking costs for cleanup and monitoring. Cases often require coordination with environmental laboratories, medical providers, and regulatory agencies such as state health departments or environmental protection programs. Statutes of limitation and notice requirements can vary depending on the claim type, so timely preservation of evidence, written records of exposure, and professional testing results are essential to maintain legal remedies and build a compelling case against responsible entities.

Need More Information?

Key Terms You Should Know

TENORM Defined

TENORM stands for Technologically Enhanced Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material and refers to naturally occurring radioactive elements that become concentrated or dispersed as a result of industrial processes. Unlike material that is deliberately made radioactive, TENORM originates in nature but can pose hazards when operations like oil and gas production, coal combustion, and mineral processing collect or redistribute radioactive elements. Understanding what qualifies as TENORM requires environmental sampling and analysis, including measuring contamination levels and identifying pathways through which people and property may be exposed to radioactive particles or contaminated media.

Radiation Dose and Measurement

Radiation dose refers to the amount of ionizing radiation absorbed by a person or object and is assessed by professionals using standardized units and instruments. Environmental reports may list activity levels, concentrations, or dose estimates rather than simple presence or absence. Interpreting those numbers requires context about exposure duration, the specific isotopes involved, and how emissions were released or accumulated. Regulatory agencies provide guidance on acceptable levels for certain land uses and occupational settings, while health assessments focus on whether doses exceed thresholds associated with potential biological effects and whether medical monitoring is advisable.

Exposure Pathways

Exposure pathways describe the routes by which radioactive material can reach humans, animals, or the environment. Typical pathways include inhalation of airborne dust or aerosols, ingestion of contaminated water or food, direct contact with contaminated soil or surfaces, and secondary exposure from contaminated materials brought into homes or workplaces. Identifying likely pathways is essential to targeted testing, protective measures, and remedial planning. Legal claims often center on proving that a release created a plausible pathway to a claimant and that the pathway resulted in measurable contamination or adverse impacts to health or property.

Regulatory Standards and Agencies

Regulatory standards for TENORM vary by material type, use, and state implementation. Federal agencies offer guidance, while state environmental and health departments set enforceable limits, testing protocols, and cleanup requirements. In West Virginia, relevant authorities may include state environmental and public health divisions that oversee sampling, notifications, and remediation where contamination is found. Legal claims frequently interact with regulatory processes, using official testing results and agency findings to support claims for cleanup, compensation, or injunctive relief against parties who failed to follow applicable safety and disposal practices.

PRO TIPS

Document Exposure Immediately

Begin documenting suspected TENORM exposure as soon as possible by taking clear photographs of affected areas, noting dates and times of observations, and collecting contact information for any witnesses or coworkers who may have observed the same issues. Preserve any materials that may contain contamination, such as soil samples, clothing, or equipment parts, and avoid altering the scene where practical to preserve evidence integrity. Keep records of communications with employers, property owners, or regulatory agencies, and request copies of any incident reports or testing results that arise from initial investigations.

Seek Medical Evaluation and Monitoring

If you believe you have been exposed to TENORM, schedule a medical assessment to document symptoms, baseline conditions, and any recommended follow‑up monitoring or testing. Keep detailed medical records that link your health concerns to the exposure incident, including dates, provider notes, diagnostic tests, and prescribed treatments. Medical documentation can be important evidence in a claim for personal injury or medical monitoring, and early records help establish timelines and demonstrate that health issues emerged after or in connection with the identified exposure.

Preserve Physical and Documentary Evidence

Preserve physical items that may have been in contact with contamination, including clothing, tools, filters, or packaging; store these items in sealed containers and label them with dates and context. Maintain thorough documentary evidence such as property deeds, maintenance logs, discharge records, or communications about hazardous materials handling. Obtaining and retaining official testing reports, incident notifications, and correspondence with companies or agencies strengthens any legal claim by creating a chain of information that shows what was known, when it was known, and how the contamination was handled or left unaddressed.

Comparing Legal Paths for TENORM Matters

When a Comprehensive Approach Is Appropriate:

Complex Contamination Involving Multiple Parties

Comprehensive legal action is often necessary when contamination affects large areas or involves multiple potentially responsible parties, such as contractors, waste handlers, and property owners. These cases require coordinated investigation, environmental testing, allocation of responsibility among parties, and often negotiation or litigation to secure cleanup and compensation. A wide‑ranging approach can aggregate evidence from varied sources, support claims for community‑scale impacts, and address both individual harms and collective remediation needs that isolated claims might not fully resolve.

Long-Term Health Concerns and Monitoring Needs

When exposures raise questions about potential long‑term health effects, a comprehensive case can secure funding for ongoing medical monitoring and future care if conditions emerge over time. Such claims often require collaboration with medical professionals to design appropriate monitoring plans and to quantify the present and potential future costs. Addressing long‑term needs up front ensures that the response to contamination includes preventive health measures and financial resources to manage medical surveillance and any treatment that becomes necessary.

When a Limited Approach May Be Sufficient:

Isolated Property Contamination

A narrower claim is often appropriate where contamination is localized to a single property and the responsible party is clearly identified, allowing a focused demand for remediation or property compensation. In these situations, targeted testing, a limited remediation plan, and direct negotiation with the responsible party or their insurer can resolve the matter efficiently. A limited approach can reduce legal costs and timeline when the issues are straightforward, the contamination is contained, and there is minimal risk of broader community impact.

Clear Responsible Party and Quick Resolution

When records clearly show which company or individual created or disposed of the TENORM, and when that party is willing to engage in corrective action or settlement discussions, a limited strategy focused on remediation and compensation may be effective. Quick resolution may secure cleanup funds and compensation without extensive litigation, particularly if environmental testing confirms the scope of contamination and responsible parties accept liability. Even in these cases, proper documentation and professional testing are essential to ensure a binding resolution that protects future interests.

Common TENORM Scenarios in West Virginia

Oilfield Scale and Brine Waste

Oil and gas operations can generate scale and brine waste containing elevated levels of naturally occurring radioactive materials, which may accumulate in pipes, tanks, and produced water residues. Improper handling, storage, or disposal of these materials can lead to soil and groundwater contamination at well sites, waste pits, or during transport, posing exposure risks to workers and nearby residents and potentially requiring investigation, testing, and legal action to secure cleanup and compensation.

Coal Ash and Combustion Residue

Coal combustion residues and ash ponds can concentrate naturally occurring radioactive elements in residues deposited at power generation sites or in landfills and ponds. When containment fails, windborne dust, groundwater infiltration, or direct contact can spread contamination to surrounding properties and water supplies, creating environmental health concerns that often require coordinated remediation, monitoring, and potential claims to address property impacts and health risks.

Scrap Metal and Recycled Materials

Scrap metal processing and recycling operations sometimes receive equipment or materials contaminated by TENORM that are not identified and separated, spreading contamination through processing facilities or into consumer markets. Improper decontamination and resale of recycled materials can lead to unexpected exposures in homes and businesses, calling for testing, recall actions, and legal remedies to address both the source of contamination and its downstream impacts.

TENORM Legal Services for Mineral Wells Residents

Why Choose Stephen New & Associates for TENORM Matters

Residents and workers in Mineral Wells and Wood County can rely on a firm that understands West Virginia practice and the practical realities of environmental and personal injury claims. Stephen New & Associates provides direct communication, coordinated investigations with environmental and medical professionals, and representation aimed at securing remediation, compensation for property loss, and recovery for health impacts. The firm assists with filing claims, preserving evidence, and negotiating with responsible parties or insurers to pursue remedies that address both immediate and potential future harms from TENORM contamination.

Handling a TENORM matter requires attention to technical testing, regulatory interaction, and sensitive client communication about health and safety. The firm works to obtain environmental testing results, consults with medical providers on appropriate evaluation and monitoring plans, and seeks just outcomes through negotiation or litigation when necessary. Clients receive clear guidance on timing, documentation needs, and possible remedies, and the firm assists in coordinating filings, notices, and collection of records that support claims for cleanup costs, diminished property value, and medical monitoring.

Contact Us About Your TENORM Concerns

People Also Search For

TENORM Mineral Wells WV

TENORM contamination West Virginia

radiation exposure claims Mineral Wells

oilfield TENORM claims Wood County

coal ash contamination West Virginia lawyer

property contamination TENORM Mineral Wells

medical monitoring TENORM claims

environmental cleanup claims Beckley WV

FAQS

What is TENORM and how might I be exposed in Mineral Wells?

TENORM stands for Technologically Enhanced Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material and refers to naturally occurring radioactive elements that become concentrated or redistributed as a result of industrial processes. In Mineral Wells, common sources include residues from oil and gas operations, coal combustion wastes, and recycled industrial materials. Exposure can occur through inhalation of contaminated dust, ingestion of impacted water or food, or direct contact with contaminated soil or surfaces. Environmental testing by qualified labs is needed to determine whether contamination levels are present and to identify likely pathways. If you suspect exposure, document the circumstances by taking photographs, saving potentially contaminated items, and recording dates, times, and any communications with employers or property owners. Early documentation and testing help preserve legal options and support medical evaluations. Contacting public health or environmental authorities may prompt official sampling, which can be important evidence in any claim or cleanup process.

What health concerns are associated with TENORM exposure?

Health concerns related to TENORM depend on the isotopes involved, exposure levels, and duration. Short-term exposures to low levels may not produce immediate symptoms, while longer or higher‑level exposures can increase risks for conditions associated with ionizing radiation. Medical providers can assess symptoms, recommend baseline testing, and advise on monitoring schedules tailored to the type and extent of exposure. Documenting medical visits and test results is important for both health management and any legal claim. Community and occupational exposures can lead to anxiety and concern about long‑term effects; addressing these requires coordinated medical and environmental responses. Where monitoring is recommended, establishing a written plan for periodic evaluations helps track changes over time and may form part of a legal claim seeking funding for ongoing medical oversight and related care if warranted by professional recommendations.

Who can be held responsible for TENORM contamination?

Responsible parties can include companies that generated, handled, transported, or disposed of TENORM materials, as well as property owners who failed to maintain safe storage or properly disclose contamination. Contractors, waste handlers, and recycling facilities that accepted contaminated materials may also bear liability. Identifying the responsible parties typically involves obtaining facility records, waste manifests, and operational histories to trace the source and handling of contaminated materials. In some cases, multiple entities share responsibility, and legal claims may seek to allocate costs among them for cleanup, property damage, and personal injury compensation. Insurance carriers for those entities may be involved in settlement negotiations, and regulatory agency findings or enforcement actions can support private claims by documenting violations or oversight failures.

What kinds of evidence are important in a TENORM claim?

Important evidence includes environmental testing results from qualified laboratories, photographs of affected areas, preserved clothing or materials suspected of contamination, property records, and documentation of communications with employers or waste handlers. Medical records that link symptoms or monitoring recommendations to the exposure event are also critical. Chronological records showing when contamination was observed and reported help establish timelines that may affect legal rights and notice requirements. Chain of custody for samples and preserved items strengthens their reliability in claims or litigation, so it is helpful to maintain clear labeling, storage, and documentation of who handled samples. Official reports from state or local environmental and health agencies can be particularly persuasive, as they provide independent assessments that support claims for cleanup and compensation.

How long do I have to file a claim related to TENORM exposure?

Statutes of limitation and notice requirements depend on the type of claim, such as personal injury, property damage, or cost recovery for cleanup, and they can differ by state and by claim category. Some claims begin to run when the injury or contamination is discovered, while others have fixed deadlines from the date of the harmful act. Prompt action to investigate and preserve evidence helps protect legal rights and may prevent forfeiture of claims due to missed deadlines. Because time limits can be complex, it is important to obtain timely guidance to understand the applicable deadlines for your situation. Early consultation helps ensure that required notices are filed and that preservation steps occur before critical evidence is lost or before statutory deadlines make certain remedies unavailable.

Can I get testing and cleanup of contaminated property?

Testing and cleanup can sometimes be obtained through regulatory enforcement, voluntary action by responsible parties, or as part of a settlement negotiated through a legal claim. Regulatory agencies may require remediation if testing shows contamination above established thresholds for soils, water, or air. Where agencies find violations or risks, they may order or oversee cleanup activities, but private legal action can also secure cleanup funds and monitoring when agencies do not act quickly or when parties seek compensation for property loss and health impacts. Securing cleanup often begins with professional assessment and sampling to define the scope of contamination and recommend remedial measures. Legal claims can then use those findings to demand corrective action, remediation funding, and ongoing monitoring, and to pursue compensation for losses such as decreased property value and costs associated with relocation or temporary mitigation.

Will my medical bills be covered if I was exposed?

Coverage for medical bills depends on the source of liability and the available insurance. If a responsible company or insurer accepts liability or a court finds them responsible, those parties may be required to pay for medical evaluations, diagnostic testing, treatment, and monitoring related to the exposure. Workers who are exposed on the job may have access to workers’ compensation benefits for workplace‑related injuries, though those processes differ from private claims for property damages or long‑term monitoring. Documenting medical care, costs, and treatment recommendations is essential to support claims for reimbursement or future medical monitoring funding. Legal claims can seek compensation for past and future medical expenses, and where there is uncertainty about long‑term effects, a claim can seek funding for periodic medical surveillance as part of a negotiated resolution or court order.

How does an investigation into TENORM contamination proceed?

An investigation typically begins with site assessment and environmental sampling to identify the presence and extent of TENORM contamination. Qualified environmental professionals collect soil, water, and material samples for laboratory analysis; interview witnesses; and review operational records, waste manifests, and disposal logs to trace potential sources. The investigation establishes exposure pathways, quantifies contamination levels, and informs remediation options and health assessments. Legal investigation runs in parallel with scientific inquiry, gathering documents that show how materials were handled and whether applicable safety or disposal standards were followed. Combining environmental results with operational records, communication logs, and expert input supports claims for cleanup, compensation, and injunctive relief when necessary. Official agency findings can also bolster the evidence assembled during the investigation.

Are there regulations that address TENORM in West Virginia?

Regulations that touch on TENORM may come from federal guidance and state environmental and public health rules, and implementation can vary by jurisdiction. In West Virginia, state agencies provide protocols for sampling, notification, and remediation where contamination exceeds applicable thresholds, and they may coordinate with federal programs on issues that cross jurisdictional lines. Regulatory findings and enforcement actions can provide important documentation that contamination exists and that responsible parties failed to meet applicable standards. Because regulatory frameworks and cleanup criteria evolve, professional testing that follows accepted protocols is often necessary to produce results that are meaningful for regulatory and legal purposes. Understanding which standards apply and how agencies interpret results in specific contexts helps shape remedial plans and legal strategies to address contamination effectively and to secure appropriate remedies.

What should workers do if they suspect workplace TENORM exposure?

Workers who suspect workplace TENORM exposure should report the concerns to their employer and safety officer, seek medical evaluation promptly, and request documentation of the report in writing or by email to establish an official record. It is important to preserve any clothing, equipment, or worksite materials that may be contaminated and to avoid laundering or discarding potentially contaminated items until testing can occur. Following workplace reporting protocols helps preserve rights under workers’ compensation and supports any subsequent claims for employer liability or additional remedies. If workplace reporting does not result in appropriate testing or mitigation, workers may consider contacting state health or environmental agencies to request inspection and sampling. Maintaining a record of all steps taken, medical visits, and communications strengthens potential claims and can prompt regulatory attention when immediate employer action is lacking.