Settlement Alerts:
  • $9,250,000 Defamation Case Win Against The New York Times 8/26
  • $6,800,000 Wrongful Death 8/26
  • $81,000,000 Children Born Addicted (as part of the trial team)
  • $18,000,000 Product Liability 12/19
  • $13,000,000 Medical Malpractice – Sexual Assault 8/23
  • $225,000 Civil Litigation 7/26
  • $50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
  • $30,000 Medical Malpractice 7/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
  • $42,690 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/26
  • $2,759,223 Opioid Litigation 6/26
  • $70,000 Medical Malpractice 6/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 6/26
  • $100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
  • $420,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/26
  • $650,000 Jail Litigation 5/26
  • $46,937 Opioid Litigation 5/26
  • $150,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 5/26
  • $285,000 Medical Malpractice 4/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
  • $50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
  • $50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 3/26
  • $50,000 Personal Injury 3/26
  • $40,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
  • $50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
  • $32,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/26
  • $42,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 1/26
  • $30,000 Personal Injury 1/26
  • $50,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 12/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
  • $77,500 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 11/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
  • $26,668 Personal Injury 9/25
  • $25,000 Personal Injury 9/25
  • $97,500 Personal Injury 9/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 9/25
  • $100,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 8/25
  • $100,000 Wrongful Death 7/25
  • $45,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 7/25
  • $200,000 Wrongful Death 6/25
  • $1,200,000 Wrongful Death – Jail Litigation 6/25
  • $200,000 Slip & Fall 6/25
  • $26,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
  • $800,000 Jail Litigation 5/25
  • $925,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 5/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
  • $125,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
  • $700,000 Jail Litigation 4/25
  • $25,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 4/25
  • $125,000 Personal Injury 4/25
  • $20,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
  • $1,300,000 Jail Litigation 2/25
  • $210,000 Slip & Fall 2/25
  • $100,000 Motor Vehicle Accident 2/25
  • $975,000 Medical Malpractice 1/25
  • $4,000,000 Jail Litigation 1/25
View All
5-Star Google Rating•BBB Rating: A+•West Virginia State Bar•The United States District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia•The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals•The United States Supreme Court•American Association for Justice•Opioid Justice Team•Trial Lawyers Care•West Virginia Association for Justice•5-Star Google Rating•BBB Rating: A+•West Virginia State Bar•The United States District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia•The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals•The United States Supreme Court•American Association for Justice•Opioid Justice Team•Trial Lawyers Care•West Virginia Association for Justice

Parked Car, Fatal Crash: What WV’s UIM Ruling Means for Families

Facebook
LinkedIn
Reddit
X
WhatsApp
Print

When a serious crash takes a life or changes one forever, families often discover that the at-fault driver’s insurance is not enough to cover what was lost. A November 2026 decision from West Virginia’s highest court may make it harder for insurers to use fine print to limit what injured people and grieving families can recover from their own policies. Here is what happened and what it could mean for you.

What Happened

According to reports, on November 23, 2019, a driver traveling the wrong way on Ohio State Route 7 collided head-on with an oncoming vehicle. Five people died, including the wrong-way driver and the owner of the car he was driving, who was riding in her own vehicle as a passenger.

The passenger’s estate reportedly received $120,000 from the combined liability coverage available. Both liability policies involved carried limits of $100,000 per person and $300,000 per accident. The estate maintained that this amount fell far short of its losses.

The estate then turned to underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, the part of an auto policy that can pay when the at-fault driver’s insurance runs out. Its claim was made under the passenger’s own policy with Milbank Insurance Company. The estate’s argument was unusual: the driver separately owned another car, insured by Erie Insurance Property and Casualty Company, which was parked at his home during the crash. The estate argued that this uninvolved car qualified as an “underinsured motor vehicle” because West Virginia’s statute does not require that vehicle to be part of the accident.

Milbank’s policy language added a requirement that the at-fault person’s liability arise from the ownership, maintenance, or use of the underinsured vehicle itself. The Circuit Court of Ohio County sided with the estate. The Intermediate Court of Appeals reversed, focusing on the policy’s wording. On November 13, 2026, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals reversed again and reinstated the circuit court’s ruling, holding that the policy provision was narrower than state law allows and therefore could not be enforced. Two justices dissented.

Importantly, other claims were sent back to the lower court, including allegations that Milbank’s UIM selection forms were defective and claims of bad faith and unfair settlement practices. No court has ruled on the merits of those claims.

Who May Be Liable

In a crash like this one, several parties could share responsibility or owe payment:

  • The at-fault driver or the driver’s estate. A driver who allegedly causes a crash may be liable for the harm, and a claim can often proceed against the estate if that driver has died. Payment typically comes from liability insurance.
  • Your own insurance company. Your UIM carrier is not at fault for the crash, but it may owe you benefits under your contract when the at-fault driver’s coverage is too small.
  • An insurer that mishandles a claim. If a company allegedly delays, underpays, or denies a valid claim, it could face separate liability for bad faith.
  • Other parties, depending on the facts. In some crashes, an employer, a vehicle owner, or a government entity responsible for a dangerous roadway could be liable. Nothing in the reports suggests these apply here, but every case deserves a full investigation.

Legal Theories That May Apply

  • Negligence: A driver who fails to use reasonable care, such as by traveling the wrong way, may be responsible for resulting injuries.
  • Wrongful death: West Virginia law allows a personal representative to bring a claim on behalf of family members when negligence causes a death.
  • Underinsured motorist (contract) claim: A policyholder may seek UIM benefits from their own insurer under West Virginia Code § 33-6-31 and the policy.
  • Defective UIM offer or selection form: If an insurer did not properly offer optional UIM coverage, a court may find higher coverage applies than the policy states.
  • First-party bad faith and unfair claim settlement practices: An insurer that allegedly mistreats its own policyholder could be liable for added damages under West Virginia law.

Damages Victims May Recover

Depending on the facts, injured people and families may be able to recover:

  • Medical bills, both past and future
  • Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
  • Pain, suffering, and emotional distress
  • Funeral and burial expenses in fatal cases
  • Under West Virginia’s wrongful death statute (W. Va. Code § 55-7-6), damages for family members’ sorrow, mental anguish, and loss of companionship and guidance, plus lost financial support and services
  • Loss of consortium for a spouse
  • Punitive damages in limited cases involving especially reckless conduct, which West Virginia generally caps
  • In bad-faith cases, potential additional damages such as attorney fees and costs

Evidence That Strengthens a Case

  • Police and crash reconstruction reports
  • Photos, dashcam footage, and traffic or surveillance video
  • Witness statements
  • Medical records, autopsy reports, and death certificates
  • Every insurance policy that may apply, including declarations pages and endorsements
  • Signed UIM selection or rejection forms
  • Records of vehicles owned by the at-fault driver
  • All letters, emails, and claim notes exchanged with insurers
  • Proof of income, bills, and other financial losses

What to Do Next

  • Get medical care and keep records. Write down symptoms, appointments, and how injuries affect daily life.
  • Request copies of your full policy. Ask for every endorsement and any coverage form you signed.
  • Preserve evidence. Keep photos, receipts, and correspondence in one place.
  • Be careful with insurers. Avoid recorded statements or signing releases before getting legal advice, even with your own company.
  • Watch the deadlines. Most West Virginia injury and wrongful death claims must be filed within two years, and other claims may have different time limits.

If you or a loved one has been harmed by negligence or wrongdoing in West Virginia, contact New Law Office in Beckley for a free, confidential consultation. We work on contingency – you pay nothing unless we win your case. Call (304) 355-5565 or visit https://newlawoffice.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use my own insurance if the driver who hit me didn’t have enough coverage?

You may be able to, if your policy includes underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage. UIM can pay the difference between the at-fault driver’s liability limits and your actual losses, up to your coverage limits. Your insurer may still dispute the amount, so it helps to have your policy reviewed.

Does the at-fault driver’s car have to be involved in the crash for my UIM coverage to apply?

Under the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals’ November 2026 decision, an insurer cannot require that the underinsured vehicle be involved in the accident. The court found that a policy term adding that requirement was more restrictive than state law and unenforceable. How this applies to your situation depends on your policy and the facts.

How long do I have to file a car accident or wrongful death claim in West Virginia?

Most personal injury and wrongful death claims in West Virginia must be filed within two years. Insurance contract and bad-faith claims may have different deadlines, and exceptions can apply. Speaking with an attorney early helps protect your rights.

What if I signed a form turning down underinsured motorist coverage?

West Virginia requires insurers to offer optional UIM coverage in a proper way. If the offer or selection form was allegedly defective, a court may find that coverage exists at higher limits than your policy lists. An attorney can examine the forms you signed.

The crash happened in Ohio. Can West Virginia law still apply?

It may. In the case discussed here, the crash reportedly occurred in Ohio, yet West Virginia courts applied West Virginia’s UIM statute to the policy. Which state’s law controls can depend on where the policy was issued and where the insured lived.

What can I do if my insurance company is stalling or lowballing my UIM claim?

Keep copies of every letter, email, and claim note, and avoid accepting a settlement under pressure. If an insurer allegedly handles a claim unfairly, it could face a separate bad-faith claim under West Virginia law. A lawyer can evaluate whether the conduct crosses that line.

Can my family recover if a loved one died as a passenger?

Yes, a family may have a wrongful death claim against the at-fault driver or that driver’s estate. Depending on the policies involved, UIM benefits may also be available. A personal representative usually brings the claim on behalf of the family.

Original reporting: insurancebusinessmag.com.


Table of Contents

Parked Car, Fatal Crash: What WV’s UIM Ruling Means for Families

Recent Blogs

Site Navigation

Legal Services